top of page
  • Writer's pictureTITAN

Deserting X Amidst Disinformation and Hate Speech Scandals

In the ever-evolving landscape of social media, the platform formerly known as Twitter, now referred to as X, finds itself in the eye of a storm as a cascade of controversies engulfs its reputation. Recent revelations of pro-Nazi content surfacing alongside advertisements have triggered a mass exodus of advertisers, further compounded by Elon Musk's endorsement of a baseless anti-Semitic conspiracy theory to his colossal following of 163 million users. As major players like IBM and the European Commission sever ties, and entertainment giants like Disney and Warner Bros. pull their ads, we at TITAN wonder if these seismic shifts in the social media realm underscore a growing demand for accountability and a collective refusal to tolerate hate speech and misinformation.

Graphic showing peopl desertiing X by walking away from the logo

X, once hailed as a microblogging pioneer, now faces a reckoning as a European Commission study points to its dubious distinction of having the highest proportion of disinformation among six major social networks. This revelation serves as the backdrop to a growing disillusionment with the platform, prompting users and advertisers alike to reassess their digital presence.

Adding fuel to the fire, Elon Musk, the owner of X, has come under scrutiny for endorsing an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory to his vast Twitter following. The revelation sent shockwaves through the social media landscape, intensifying concerns about the platform's role in amplifying harmful narratives and prompting a wave of advertiser withdrawals.

IBM, a stalwart in the tech industry, recently announced that it would cease advertising on X, citing a "zero tolerance for hate speech and discrimination." This decisive move set the stage for a domino effect, with other industry leaders following suit.

Latest Leaver the Mayor of Paris

This week Anne Hidalgo, the Mayor of Paris, has added her voice to those deserting Twitter, making a bold announcement on her official X account on November 27. Hidalgo declared that she would no longer use the Elon Musk-owned social media platform, formerly known as Twitter. Her decision is grounded in severe accusations against the platform, citing its role in inciting hate, spreading disinformation, and promoting anti-Semitic speech.

In her poignant post, Hidalgo wrote, "I have made the decision to leave Twitter." She went on to elaborate on the motivations behind her departure, expressing deep concerns about the platform's evolution. Hidalgo lamented that Twitter, once hailed as a revolutionary tool for information access, has in recent years transformed into what she described as a "weapon of mass destruction of our democracies."

The Paris Mayor did not mince words when detailing the myriad issues she sees with the platform. Her accusations ranged from manipulation and disinformation to the amplification of impulses of hatred and organized harassment. Notably, she called out instances of anti-Semitism and racism, pointing to packs attacking various groups, including scientists, climatologists, women, ecologists, progressives, and anyone seeking a peaceful political debate in an increasingly complex world.

Hidalgo's critique did not stop at Twitter itself; she also implicated the X platform and its owner, Elon Musk. Musk was accused by Hidalgo of deliberately acting to exacerbate tensions and conflicts. A bold move by the Mayor of Paris to underscore the growing disillusionment with major social media platforms and their impact on public discourse.

European Rift Grows

Could we be seeing the start of prominent figures taking a stand against platforms like Twitter, giving the debate around the responsibility of social media giants in curbing disinformation, hate speech, and promoting healthy online discourse momentum? Hidalgo's departure from Twitter serves as a powerful statement and prompts users to reflect on the role of social media in shaping our digital landscapes. But is it enough?

Other organisations seem to think the time is right. The European Commission, condemning X's promotion of hate speech, declared during a recent press briefing said that it would no longer advertise on any social media platform. Major entertainment powerhouses also joined the exodus. Disney, Comcast NBCUniversal, Warner Bros., Lionsgate, Paramount Global, and Apple all declared on Saturday morning that they were pulling ads from X. This collective departure of advertisers serves as a resounding rebuke to the platform, signalling a shared commitment to prioritising ethical considerations in digital advertising partnerships. This withdrawal of advertisers from X reflects a broader industry trend where companies are increasingly aligning their partnerships with social responsibility. As platforms face heightened scrutiny for their role in disseminating harmful content, there is a growing demand for robust measures to ensure online spaces remain safe and free from hate speech.

Australia Excluding X

Speaking of robust measures, Australia's Digital Industry Group (DIGI), the prominent industry association overseeing online safety, privacy, and cybersecurity, has also decided to take a stand against the social media platform. DIGI, representing organizations invested in maintaining the integrity of online spaces, has chosen to withdraw X's place in the voluntary code that governs efforts to curb the spread of misinformation.

This decision comes after X earned the dubious distinction of having its signatory status to the Australian Code of Practice on Disinformation and Misinformation (ACPDM) revoked. The move follows a complaint filed against the platform, specifically regarding its handling—or lack thereof—of reports of misinformation during a crucial period. The controversy unfolded in the lead-up to a referendum in Australia, offering citizens the opportunity to amend their constitution.

The proposed constitutional change aimed to establish a Voice to Parliament for Australia's indigenous people, sparking vivid and prolonged debates. Amidst this critical moment in the nation's history, concerns were raised about X's role in disseminating misinformation related to the referendum. The withdrawal of X's signatory status from the ACPDM signals a significant response to these concerns, as DIGI takes a firm stance against platforms that fail to address the responsible dissemination of information during pivotal national discussions.

This move by DIGI underscores the increasing scrutiny that social media platforms face regarding their responsibility in preventing the spread of misinformation, especially during significant events with potential societal impact. As platforms like X come under the spotlight for their role in shaping public discourse, industry associations and regulatory bodies are stepping up efforts to hold them accountable and maintain the integrity of digital spaces. The withdrawal of X from the ACPDM is a noteworthy development that further fuels the ongoing conversation about the responsibilities of tech giants in fostering a safe and informed online environment.

Are we Entering a New Era of Disinformation Awareness? Overall, the shifts in the social media landscape, marked by advertiser withdrawals and public condemnations, highlight the urgent need for platforms like X to address the disinformation and hate speech plaguing their spaces. As users and advertisers start to leave the platform, the message is clear: the era of unchecked harmful content on social media is coming to an end. A shift in thinking that initiatives like TITAN who are working hard to counter disinformation fully supports. X itself now stands at a crossroads, facing the formidable challenge of rebuilding trust and credibility in a digital landscape that increasingly values accountability and responsible content dissemination.

For more information on TITAN's approach to countering disinformation sign up via the registration form in the email footer. Thanks.

47 views0 comments
bottom of page